Cincinnatus Insurance

Category:	Insurance Agency
Address:	4790 Red Bank Expy #207, Cincinnati, OH 45227, USA
Phone:	+1 513-587-3553
Site:	cincinnatusinsurance.com
Rating:	5
Working:	9AM–6PM 9AM–6PM 9AM–6PM 9AM–6PM 9AM–6PM 9AM–1PM Closed

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 54

Jeff Cefalu

Nick has been insuring my auto body collision repair facility for over 3 years now. In a changing marketplace, he does a great job at reviewing our options BEFORE our renewal & excels in keeping us informed of our options and coverage. When we request information or documentation, he is consistently going above and beyond to make sure that we have what we need. I would recommend his service to ANY small business owner in the Greater Cincinnati region. Thanks Nick! Regards, Jeff Cefalu/ President Cefalu & Son Auto Body and Frame Goshen, OH

Evan Milz

I was with All-State all of my life, as I was born into the relationship. Came to purchase my first house and they quoted me a huge price. Decided to shop, found Nick, and he was able to save me $900 on my home insurance and as an added sweetener managed $10 off my Auto Premium to consolidate elsewhere. Super easy, friendly, and professional. Extremely satisfied and will be recommending him to my friends, family and colleagues.

Michael Santoro

Nobody likes paying more for insurance than they need to, and with Cincinnatus Insurance you can rest assured you never will pay too much for insurance ever again. As an independent agent, Nick was able to shop multiple insurance companies to get the best price for the most comprehensive coverage to suit my insurance needs. On top of all that he provides timely and excellent customer service that exceeded my expectations.

Kyle Faehr

Nick has always done right by my wife and I. Recently bought a motorcycle and needed insurance quick. Called him closer to the end of day on a Friday, he took all my info and had a call promptly Monday morning will all the details I needed. He also made himself available, and answered quickly whenever I called to ensure I was taken care of. Will continue to use his service.

David Viox

All of my dealings with Cincinnatus Insurance have been exceptional. Nick Thalhammer, the owner, is my contact. He is extremely professional, enthusiastic, honest, and always willing to go the extra step. As an independent agent, Nick represents a lot of great insurance companies so he has a lot of options for his clients. Call him-I think you will be glad you did. Dave V.

James Calloway

What a great company to work with. They are very competent with their products that they offer and the different insurance carriers they represent. Cincinnatus Insurance will help design a plan that works best for your needs and your budget. Call Nick Thalhammer and tell him James sent you. James Calloway Calloway Cleaning & Restoration Cincinnati, OH

Caroline Martini

Nick at Cincinnatus Insurance has done a great job as our insurance provider! He is always available for our questions and takes the time to answer them thoroughly. When we had a small mishap, he was very easy to work with and submit a claim. I would highly recommend Nick and Cincinnatus for your insurance needs!

Chris Hicks

Nick Thalhammer of Cincinnatus Insurance provides a great professional service and has access to very competitive rates. I recently had to make a claim and Nick walked me through the process resulting in a quick resolution and pay out from the insurance company. Comes highly recommended.

Ashton Wilson

I was referred to Nick. My experience with Nick has been great. Nick was professional, thorough, and provided many options, with competitive premiums, that exactly met our needs. Being a younger couple we needed someone who cared. Working with Nick and Cincinnatus Insurance has been great.

Ron Graham

My experience with Chris Kraus has been top notch. Chris was professional, thorough, and provided insurance options, with competitive premiums, that exactly met my needs. Working with Chris and Cincinnatus Insurance has been smooth and efficient. You should call them ! R. Graham

junior frazier

My fiancee and I have had the pleasure of having Nick as our insurance agent for the last 4 or 5 years. He has ALWAYS went above and beyond to assist us. He is knowledgeable, friendly, and takes wonderful care of his clients. Thank you so much for all your help!

Rob B

Friendly, knowledgeable service! We recently moved to Cincinnati and needed insurance for our automobiles and new home. Nick was a pro at answering all our questions and helping us find the right insurance plan to fit our needs and budget. Highly recommended!

Mathius Dillon

Nick was VERY responsive and took the time to explain everything. Nick assisted me during my first home purchase .I was very pleased with how much attention I received from him and his willingness to talk through my options for Home & Auto Insurance.

Olivia Zapf

Nick worked with me and my soon to be fiancé to get the best rate for our homeowners insurance as first time buyers. He responds back quickly and respectfully to every question we had. I would recommend him to family and friends any day.

Barbara Parsons

Cincinnatus Insurance takes care of all our insurance needs with ease and accuracy. We feel that any questions that we have, are answered quickly and with assurance that our needs are taken care of. Customer Service with Value Galore!!

Gary Motz

Nick has gone out of his way to provide timely premium comparisons, has re-shopped new options for when I moved out of state, and even been of great assistance when troubles arise. Nick is a fantastic agent that I highly recommend.

Annalise Ruzicka

Nick has been nothing but an amazing guy to work with! He is very accommodating and extremely reliable for my family and me! Nick has gotten us the best rates available, and is very hardworking. I strongly recommend Cincinnatus!

Steve Spiegla

Nick has always been very attentive to my needs and concerns. He has gone out of his way to find me better prices without even asking him to do so. I am very happy with the level of service and options Nick has provided.

Gordon Reeves

Thanks for all your hard work in finding me the best rates available. Nick is a very hard working agent, returns all calls in a timely manner and gets the best rates available. Keep up the good work, strongly recommend!

Tania Jones

I have been working with Nick Thalhammer for several years and he has always been professional, courteous, and efficient. I would not change agents or dealings with Cincinnatus at all! Thank you for all you do!

Jim Toon

I’m the co-owner of Solution Designs and our business insurance is with Cincinnatus Insurance. I have been extremely happy with the service and rates this agency has found for my business over the years.

Mike Schoose

Nick Thalhammer was professional and knowledgeable, not to mention timely. The entire experience with Cincinnatus from beginning to end was very favorable and I would recommend them without question.

Christen Logsdon

We highly recommend Cincinnatus Insurance! We saved a substantial amount of money when we first switched, and continue to pay that same low rate. We always get quick responses and excellent service.

Holly Skeens

Chris at Cincinnatus Insurance worked diligently to help us get the coverage we needed for our first home. He helped us with quotes, getting us a multi-policy discount that fit our needs perfectly.

Scott Sharrock

There is no better company to provide insurance services. Cincinnatus Insurance continues to always go over and above. I truly feel that its the best customer service that you can receive.

Randy Morris

Nick did a wonderful job, he was quick and very professional most importantly he saved me a ton of money on my car insurance. I would refer Nick to anybody that enjoys outstanding service!

Lyn Hayes

Love what Nick has been able to do for me so far. Very personable, quick to reply, found me great rates! I hope I never need him, but I feel he will have my back if I do! :)

Steven Petrovic

Cincinnatus Insurance is first class in every regards. The owner/agent is always willing to go the extra mile and works hard to make my cost go as low as possible.

Annie Miller

Huge thanks to Nick for always shopping our insurance options for the absolute best price! We are truly grateful for his superior service and prompt follow up!

bazimmer

Nick was awesome. He was able to find me better insurance than I previously had and did a great job of explaining my new policy. I would recommend to anyone.

Marita Hartel

Thanks for suggesting a good, reasonable roofer to fix our leak. Just a small example of the care you have taken in serving our insurance needs and more!

Laurence Baibak

Nick is very responsive and easy to work with. Whenever we need to update or change our insurance, he makes the process as simple as possible for us.

Joann Cook

Nick was extremely helpful in finding the best policy for our car and home insurance needs! Very pleased with the service he gave me!!

Sarah Renner

Chris was very helpful! He was efficient and found us the best deal possible. Would recommend them to all of my friends and family!

Paul Thalhammer

Customer service is outstanding!!! They shop all the companies with great ratings! They saved me a bunch on my Life Insurance!

Amanda Thalhammer

Nice agent with a good sense of humor! I can tell the agency works hard to shop around and find best deal for its customers.

Joe-Celeste Santoro

Nick has done a great job finding us great rates on our rental properties and personal home and autos. Highly recommend.

trevor campbell

Nick is fantastic. Shopped around my insurance to get the best deal. Saved me money on both policies. Highly recommend!

Jacob Sager

They insured me when no one else could or would. An excellent company to deal with. Thank you Chris for helping me out.

Benjamin Mirtes

Nick is great to work with, explains policy details clearly, and works to find the best deal - I highly recommend.

Traci Koepfer

Nick at Cincinnatus Insurance was very helpful in quoting out our insurance to get us the best coverage and value!

Barb Jackson

Nick did a great job finding us insurance and was prompt and easy to work with. I would highly recommend him.

Matt Glassmeyer

Nick really knows his stuff and truly cares about helping his clients. He is in it for all the right reasons.

Linda kunkel

Nick is fantastic--great sense of urgency and follow through. He got me the best rates and coverage EVER!

Sarah Pacini

Chris was extremely helpful processing my information so quickly! Very helpful, friendly and efficient!

Ryan Cook

Insurance brokers exist for a reason; shop insurance... use a broker... save money. Well done Nick!

Carl sheley

Very good service, and very fast and accurate I would definitely recommend this to everyone.

Nicholas Hornsby

Nick was great and he found the best rates for me. I would highly recommend them.

Kaleigh Courts

The best place to get the best rates on insurance! Thanks Nick for all your help!

Catie Hornsby

Very easy to work with! Extremely nice and will walk you through every step!

Prem Eeswar

Cincinnatus Insurance/Nick can find you the best price in the market !!!

Leah Den Herder

Great experience. Highly recommend Cincinnatus Insurance!

Riesa Burnett

Professional, knowledgeable and attentive

Terri Walker

Excellent service and great rates!

Cincinnatus Insurance

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 54

25 most recent searches

See also other insurance companies: