Mayville Insurance

Reviews 28

JU

Julie Hodges

I have used Mayville Insurance for commercial and personal policies for years. I had joined a group of network referrals and changed my insurance and did I ever regret that. I came back to Tracy, as she really knows her job. She is VERY thorough at explaining everything and gets you the best commercial coverage you can get at the best price. My change to someone who did not have my personal best interest at heart, as Mayville insurance does, cost me a loss of over 30K. I would refer Mayville Insurance to anyone who wants great customer service, makes sure you are covered properly and even followed up to make sure coverage is working and to see if any questions. Best insurance company I have used in my 40 years. Thank you Tracy and Cindy for all of your help!

---

NE

Nenno Products LLC

Within the last year I switched all of my business and personal insurance policies over to Mayville Insurance. Jenny Harbin has been awesome to work with, making sure that every detail is taken care of. We recently had a loss and needed to make a claim. Jenny often called to check on the progress and to make sure that we were happy with the service that we were receiving from the insurance company. If I had questions regarding the claim, she personally called the company and got my answers. Mayville Insurance has outstanding service!

---

RO

Robert Tiegs

You leave the office with the feeling like you got a good friend who keeps an eye on you and gets you what you need not what the big companies are pushing. I dont worry about asking around to people at work what they are paying for Car and Home insurance , because when Mayville Insurance finds a better deal on a quality policy ,they notify me without me having to ask if there is something better. They are the pleasant part of having insurance and the by far the best agency Ive ever had.

---

KI

Kim Weinberger

My husband and I have trusted Mayville Insurance with all of our personal and business insurance needs for many years. I am completely confident that we are fully protected with the best possible policies to fit our needs and budget, and every time we have had a claim they have gone above and beyond to assist us through the process. I would not trust anyone else with protecting my business or my family!

---

JU

Justin Weinberger

I have been with Mayville Insurance for a number of years and have always been extremely happy with the company and the services they provide. Any questions or requests I have are always answered quickly and completely. I get all of my insurance through them and recommend them to anyone looking for a company that will do the research to get you exactly what you need at the best price that can be found.

---

RI

Richard Cochran

For the past 12 or so years that I have been a customer here they have been great. They have always found the most affordable rate for my car insurance. Five years ago when my wife and I bought a house they helped us with combining our home and auto. In all of my experience I definitely only have good things to say about this company

---

RH

Rhonda Klemme

I have been with Mayville Insurance a long time because of great customer service. We work with Michelle, but have always been treated right by the whole staff. They personally went above what was expected to help me out. Thanks for everything!

---

SH

Shawn Reilly

great company to deal with always friendly and there responses are fast.i have been with them for about 15 years now and they are always looking for the best deal us. thanks mayville insurance keep up the good work.

---

KE

Kevin Seering

Top notch insurance agency!!!! Very informative, helpful, easy to file claims, & just an all around good staff & atmosphere!!!!! Would definitely recommend to anyone for all their insurance needs!!!!!

---

SU

Susan Retzlaff

Mayville Insurance is superior in customer service! The staff is knowledgeable, friendly and they will "give it their all"" to satisfy their customers. I highly recommend them.

---

JE

Jessica Held

Michele has been great to work with. Very knowledgeable staff and they helped our transition with insurance companies go smooth. I would highly recommend Mayville Insurance.

---

SA

sara scherr

Great people to talk to they are very knowledgeable and respond quickly to your questions!!! Thank you for your dedication and service. Great people to work with!!!!

---

LI

Lisa Delvaux

We previously had small town insurance agency that closed up, we so happy that Mayville Insurance Agency provides that personal small town touch that we love.

---

AL

Alyssa Thimmesch

The reps at Mayville Insurance are very friendly and easy to work with. My agent has done a wonderful job setting up a policy tailored to my needs!

---

BR

Brian Elmhorst

I have been a happy customer with Mayville Insurance since 1998. They have been pleasant to work with and dependable in times of emergency.

---

JA

Jackie Dean

They are always available when calling for questions and concerns. They are professional in making me feel that I am important to them.

---

KU

Kurt Stortz

Great people to work with.Prompt and friendly customer service anytime I may have a question.Great place to have all my insurance with.

---

JE

Jeff S.

Mayville Insurance has been great to work with. They are always there to give us quotes and figure the best way to insure our stuff.

---

JO

Joe Widmer

We have them for both business and personal insurance. Outstanding insurance agents. Great service and very punctual.

---

DE

Deana & Kurt Neis

The team at Mayville Insurance is very friendly and extremely knowledgeable. We recommend them to everyone.

---

AS

Ashley S

Mayville Insurance has great customer service. They have a quick response time whenever I have questions.

---

TO

Todd Kruger

Great company, great service, and great people! I highly recommend Mayville insurance to everyone.

---

ME

Megan Jacoby

All of my questions and concerns are answered in a timely manner.

---

SA

Sandra Finke

A great agency. Have never encountered problems.

---

KA

Kathy Benter

Very professional and responsive to our needs.

---

BE

Becky Giese

Have always had fast friendly service.

---

DI

Diana Unger

Exceptional Customer Service!

---

JU

Judie Hesprich

Top notch Insurance Agency!

---

---

25 most recent searches

---

---

See also other insurance companies: